Skip to main content

4 Retirement Income Styles Every Physician Should Know

A dirt road forking in the middle of a forest

Key Points:

You know you’re supposed to save and invest for retirement throughout your career. But what are you supposed to do with those savings once you’re near retirement? Most physicians have no idea, and for good reason – creating a sustainable retirement spending plan is far more complicated than saving for retirement. Planning your retirement finances is one of the most common reasons late-career docs will seek a financial planner.

The problem – a financial planning firm may specialize in one retirement strategy for their clients, when there are several to consider, such as investment-based approaches, bucketing approaches, annuity-based approaches. One framework for soon-to-be retirees to evaluate these strategies is the “Retirement Income Style Awareness” or RISA® methodology, a free but proprietary assessment created by Wade Pfau, Ph.D., CFA, RICP and Alex Murguía, Ph.D.

(Important disclaimer: I have no financial relationship with anybody involved with RISA®. This is not an advertisement or endorsement for RISA® or Retirement Researcher, LLC, the firm that Drs. Pfau and Murguía they lead.)

In a nutshell, RISA® focuses on two main themes that can help determine the optimal retirement strategy:

#1 Probability-Based vs. Safety-First Theme:

#2 Optionality vs. Commitment Theme:

RISA® creates a two-by-two matrix based on these two competing themes with four resulting retirement income styles:

As we go through each of the four retirement income styles, consider which resonates with you the most – it is possible more than one may make sense.

#1) Total Return – Probability-based + Optionality Oriented

The first style mirrors how most of us invest for retirement – using a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, and other assets, and developing a systematic and sustainable withdrawal strategy from which to spend in retirement. Total Return is ideal if you can be flexible with your spending (e.g. spend less during down years and loosen the purse strings when your investment portfolio does better than expected).

Significant advantages to this strategy:

Significant disadvantages to this strategy:

Achilles heels:

#2) Time Segmentation – Safety First + Optionality Oriented

Commonly known as “bucketing”, the Time Segmentation strategy involves investing differently based on when the money will be spent. For example, you might organize your investments into a short-term bucket, and intermediate-term bucket, and a long-term bucket. The short-term bucket might contain safe assets like cash or short-term bonds, and the long-term bucket might contain more volatile assets with a higher long-term expected return. The idea is that during down years, you could spend from the short-term bucket, and during up years, you could sell from the long-term bucket to replenish your short- and intermediate-term buckets.

Significant advantages to this strategy:

Significant disadvantages to this strategy:

Achilles Heels:

#3 Income Protection – Safety-First + Commitment Oriented

In the Income Protection strategy, you use some or all of your nest egg to create a lifelong stream of consistent income like a pension. The simplest example is a single-premium immediate annuity, where you pay a lump sum premium to a life insurance company, and they immediately start paying you a set amount of money per month for the rest of your life based on a set interest rate. Other common examples include a single-premium deferred annuity, where the payout doesn’t start for a set number of years, but the benefit is higher once it begins. Social security retirement benefits are also an example of Income Protection most of us will earn through our working careers.

Significant advantages to this strategy:

Significant disadvantages to this strategy:

Achilles heels:

#4 Risk Wrap – Optionality + Commitment Oriented

In the Risk Wrap strategy, retirees use variable annuities to create guaranteed lifetime income but still benefit from market returns – all in a single product. With variable annuities, you make payments to the insurance company into brokerage-like subaccounts, and you can choose investments within those accounts. If those investments do well, your annuity payment increases; if they don’t, your annuity payment decreases but never below a guaranteed minimum.

Significant advantages to this strategy:

Significant disadvantages to this strategy:

Achilles Heels:

How to approach your own retirement income planning

I encourage clients approaching retirement to ask themselves the following questions:

Whatever you decide, remember that the right retirement income plan for you and your family may be different from what your friends, colleagues, or family members are doing. That is totally fine – rather than facing this journey with anxiety or confusion, meet it with an open mind and consider this framework as a starting point to a wonderful retirement.

Sources/recommended reading:

If you would like to have a conversation about your retirement style and how you might manage the retirement transition, I’d love to chat. Schedule a free discovery call with me here.

DocEmpowered blog posts are never AI-generated.

Stanley Liu, MD, FACC is the Founder and Principal Financial Planner of DocEmpowered, LLC. He is also an independent practicing cardiologist, an award-winning medical educator, and the Advocacy Chair of Maryland’s American College of Cardiology Chapter.

Do you want the power to serve your patients, family, and community on your own terms? If you need an evidence-based financial plan to help make that power a reality, book a free discovery call here.

Get more insights by exploring the DocEmpowered Blog.

Blog feature photo credit: Alexander Lunyov on Unsplash